Ave Maria in Naples, FL
Steubenville in OH
Christendom in VA
Magdalen in Warner, NH
Thomas More in Manchester, NH
And one in San Francisco who's name escapes me right now.
Otherwise, avoid any Jesuit school (e.g. Georgetown, BC, Loyola, Gonzaga) they've left Christianty entirely.
Add Thomas Aquinas in CA to your list of real Catholic colleges.