Just what I thought. Not sure where Michelle Starr is coming from, but she clearly is wrong to say "both sides agree" on this rather fantastic claim.
That kind of jumped out at me, but I'm not the expert.
I suspect that some of us amateur FReepers are quicker on our feet than some PhDs who have not spent hours every day confronting this nonsense.
Some of the stuff is so bizarre you could never imagine it, so the first time you see it you are caught flatfooted.