Wow. How astute. I'm not an attorney. Duh...
Now, lets put Harriet Miers in the same room with Janice Rogers Brown, mano a mano, and we'll see which one knows more about the Constitution, the law, and all related cases and previous decisions. That would make a lot more sense than your stupid scenario.
My money is definitely not on Harriet. Who would you bet on?
You don't know the answer to that question, yet you already passed judgement.