[Hank Rearden]

I like the concept of everyone having to contribute in some way that benefits others.

And 9 out of 10 totalitarians agree with you. #10 is a Moslem who wants you dead.

[rlmorel]

I think perhaps you misunderstand me. Perhaps it is my fault for not being clear.

I am assuming from what you wrote that you think I am advocating socialism. Nothing could be further from the truth.

When I say "benefits others" I mean performing a task or service that provides value to society, in which they are paid in return.

This is in contrast to the panhandlers who sell "Homeless News" in Harvard Square for a dollar. The panhandlers are GIVEN the papers for free, which they then try to sell for a dollar.

It provides absolutely no value (other than propaganda for the Left)

These panhandlers are not producing anything or adding anything to society.