after attempting to build one crime scenario after another that encompasses most of the clues and theories that have evolved so far, everything keeps coming back to the boys and the lies; they aren't just doing this as a high school prank...why the lies and then silence if they don't hold all the secrets of the mystery? what could have happened that brought such supposed great and dedicated humanitarians, to hear the island chatter on it, to have to cover up something they have done? after everything that's been out there it still is as simple as three horny guys, a cute girl, loads of booze and drugs on a hot summer night on a tropical island...still go for the accidental death and pop's entry as a sort of aruban mr. wolf (Harvey Keitel--Pulp Fiction)...and if they had a sport for stonewalling in the olympics aruba would race away with the gold medal and the silver and bronze, too
of course, its also possible that we have all awoke into an alternative universe today where a National Enquirer story is actually coming true