Gonzales was the pick only in fevered minds that expected betrayal at every corner. It was not predicated on his actual record of slecting Justices.
People that doubted or believed differently, have been discredited with this pick. Whether or not they acknowledge it.
Only an idiot puts his or her blind faith in a politician. Politicians need to have their feet held to the fire. That's absolutely obligation of conservatives, not worshipping at the alter of a party or politician.