Well, I checked your link and sorry to say the writer is what I generally classify as a crank. He has a problem with mixing quotes from various sources and choosing fonts and bolding in such a way as confuse the reader as to which is what and from whom as well as being careless with quotation marks.
This is a sign of deliberate deception or disorganized thinking both in pursuit of an agenda or belief system.
If you read some of his non Narnia pages, he also makes some statements indicative of paranoid delusions of persecution and he filters his wife's and adult daughter's email before allowing them to read it (by his own statement warning against criticism of the womens pages).
Not someone I can take seriously either as a literary critic or as an advisor on theological matters, even though paranoids can have real enemies.
Fret not, ye red neck Baptist preachers. My wife Elizabeth, and Mary, my daughter, are in full submission to Christ, our Editor in Chief and to me, their pastor. Ladies, please enjoy this page in the Lord and in the King James Bible. Mail sent by Christian ladies will be answered by the ladies here unless I, Steve, believe the mail is meant only to make trouble. Such mail is deleted, and the ladies never see it.
Weird-oid, uncivil, and snobby, too. Three strikes and you're out, Steve, bless your heart.