"So all of this may be true about Dr. Thogmartin, and then again, there may be things we don't know either. We can't just look at the surface of things."
Very good. I assume everyone can also agree then that WE KNOW NOTHING about this man. We don't know if this Dr. is good or bad at his job, or if he has ulterior motives, etc. Now, finally, at least THAT is honest. So everyone who wants to damn this man without KNOWING anything can sit down now and quit making unproven accusations about him.
I would agree with that. It doesn't serve any more purpose to damn him without evidence, or to give rumors about him without backing them up, then it does to simply post his CV as an answer to those rumors. We don't know anything about this guy, at least I don't.