Again, just because something seems incompatible doesn't mean it is.
God is much bigger than you can understand Him, sooth.
I allow him to be beyond my comprehension. I know it seems contradictory, but I also know that God doesn't have contradiction.
But you've also claimed that God is perfectly logical. How does that work if God exists as a bunch of paradoxes?
If you are going to plead the ineffability of God and His Plan (a stance I can completely understand), then please refrain from invoking the "logic" of your own position on predestination and please, please refrain from your utter earnestness in your own correctness.
SD
Please hurry up and define "BAD"
for me so I will be sure and not cross
that line.