It's Thursday at the Finest... stop in and read JohnHuang2's biting take on the latest judicial nomination fight!!! Enjoy!!!
|
All bettah now, I do believe, Dear John, addressing first this:
The Deal is the product of 14 "moderates," all eagerly seeking to 'preserve' a 'long-standing, venerated Senate tradition' -- interprets as:
"all eagerly seeking to 'preserve' a 'long-standing, venerated Senate tradition'
of trying to cinch their chances for reelection,
and a firm place in history footnotes"....
[AKA known as "Inserting-Foot-in-Mouth"].....
Call it
"A Lesson on How to be Ignominious without Really Trying"
[ignominy = shameful or dishonorable quality or conduct or an instance of this)]
Presenting a Byrd's Eye View --
Next is "Which is why I give this 'Deal' a few weeks. Then it unravels. It unravels at precisely the moment Bush names Janice Rogers Brown or Priscilla Owen to the Supreme Court. Then we're right back where we were before The Deal. See how much Moderates always accomplish? These are the people who make things not happen."
"Soon, Sen. Frist brings back the "Nuclear Option," because when there's a problem, you nuke it."
It just so happens, JH, my weekly 'Dear Maggie' letter from Senator Bill Frist contains these encouraging sentences:
"The Constitution gives the Senate the power to govern itself. And we were fully committed to use that power to establish a process by which a confirmation vote would occur after reasonable debate. This approach had a lot of precedent. The minority attempted to demean it by calling it the nuclear option. But the nuclear option is what they themselves detonated with their filibuster power grab. The proper term for our response is Constitutional option, because we would rely on the Constitution's power of self-governance to restore Senate traditions barring judicial filibusters.
Against their nuclear option, the Constitutional option is the only effective antidote.
The moment of truth was to have come on May 24. But action was preempted by an agreement between seven Republicans and seven Democrats to forestall use of the Constitutional option in exchange for confirmation votes on several nominees and a promise that filibusters would only be maintained in extraordinary circumstances. I was not a party to that agreement nor was the Republican Leadership.
Now we move into a new and uncertain phase. Under the agreement, this week the Senate confirmed Priscilla Owen to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. Several more of the nominees will follow her. Priscilla Owen, a gentle lady, accomplished lawyer and brilliant Texas jurist was unconscionably denied an up or down vote for more than four years. The minority distorted her record, cast aspersions on her abilities, and rendered her almost unrecognizable. She had the fortitude to see the process through. And very late, but at long last, she was confirmed.
Without the Constitutional option, Priscilla Owen would never have come to a vote. Neither would any of the other nominees.
Without the Constitutional option, judicial filibusters would have become a standard instrument of minority party policy. The agreement is based on the trust that casual use of judicial filibusters is over.
Without the Constitutional option, the minority would have adhered to the path it was on and deal brokers would have had no deal to broker.
I am now hopeful but wary. As Ronald Reagan was fond to say, trust but verify. If nominees are confirmed and the sword of the filibuster is sheathed, then the Republican Leadership can be proud that its courage arrested a dangerous and destructive trend. If filibusters again erupt under circumstances other than extraordinary, we will put the Constitutional option back on the table and move to implement it.
-- [LadyX says HOORAY!!]
Abraham Lincoln once said that when it is not possible to do the best, it is best to do what is possible. Standing fast for the principle of fair up or down votes, we have made real progress. That is something we all can celebrate. And that principle will be our guidepost as the rest of this great Constitutional drama unfolds."
Bill Frist
Indeed, that is something we all can celebrate!!
**LadyX sidles out the door to go play in her yard some more -- waving to you** and