[xzins]

Many eyewitness accounts match corroborating or contradictory physical evidence

There is nothing in the above that the 4 categories cannot incorporate.

Given that I had already excluded #3 (intentional misleading = outright fabrication), then #4 would have been the worst case.

For whatever reason we're not communicating. Probably because I had potato chips, chili, and coffee for breakfast. :>)

[AntiGuv]

For whatever reason we're not communicating.

The reason is because you've excluded #3 (intentional misleading) and I haven't. Your stated reason for excluding #3, that people died for the belief, is nonsense. Many people have died for their beliefs and that didn't make their beliefs any more valid.

[AntiGuv]

It didn't make their beliefs any more or less valid than they were otherwise.

[AntiGuv]

The other reason we're not communicating is because your #1, #2, and #4 cases that you haven't excluded are not evidence for deities. They would be evidence for people believing they witnessed a resurrection.