[Aquinasfan]

It is not inconsistent with libertarian ideology to support controlling America's borders.

Not generally. But selectively prohibiting Mohammedan immigration would be contrary to libertarian principles, right?

[Modernman]

But selectively prohibiting Mohammedan immigration would be contrary to libertarian principles, right?

Not really. One of the legitimate roles of government is to protect the citizenry from outside threats. A good case can be made that the citizenry would be safer if Muslims were not allowed to immigrate to this country and if non-citizen Muslims already here were deported.