I'm no Mc NAbb fan, but over rated he is not. The guy is easily in the top three QBs in the league. Ask any fantasy league player.
I disagree but to each his own I guess. Until he and Manning can show me they can win the big ones, to win when it counts, I will go with the Bradys and the Montana's of the world.
So what other active QB would you put ahead of McNabb and Manning and behind Brady? If you can't name any others, haven't you just admitted they are the top 3?