Did you know that the soldier's mom gave the Iraqi woman her son's dog tags ..?? Very moving - even the President had trouble keeping it together.
But .. your comment, "it is a bad, bad idea." What makes you say that ..??
I pray today for the peace of Israel...I pray for Palestinian Christians who are doubly oppresed but love Yeshua and struggle as we do....and I pray for Judah to recognize brother Ephraim, to be reconciled as it says in Ps 133:1 and to rejoice in unity. The story is told in the life of Joseph in Genesis.
To answer your question - everytime we encourage Israel to give up its rightfull land we suffer the consequence, it is not God's purpose to depose Israel. Watch and see....Shalom