[Borges]

The previews made it look cliched and predictable. That said, its being seriously overpraised.

[jocon307]

"That said, its being seriously overpraised."

It is probably Hillary Swank, she's made a stock in trade of these "gender bending" roles, but I do think she's very good. Although I really haven't seen her in anything, I'm just a very presumptuous person I suppose.

[cryptical]

The previews made it look cliched and predictable. That said, its being seriously overpraised.

I saw the movie a couple weeks ago, and it was excellent, IMO. The only beef I had with it is that Clint Eastwood should go after himself for stealing some of the score from 'Unforgiven'.

[Dave W]

No, it is not being overpraised. It is a very powerful and moving story. Just because I don't agree with the outcome doesn't mean I am going to slam it.