Perhaps it will cause the discussion of abiogenesis to be more rigorous among those who wish to tackle a theory without boundaries, as you suggest. However, I predict more Heat than Light will be the result.
Without boundaries, nothing is. Except relentlessly subjective opinion. So natch, you're gonna get a whole lot of "heat," and zilch "light." What tortoise proposes is a fool's game, not to put too fine a point on it. JMHO FWIW.