[Right Wing Professor]

Do only football players determine what constitutes football?

Players and coaches, and coaching associations, yes. Participants in football, in other words. I haven't seen any sign that the NBA is trying to force football to abandon two-deep zone defenses.

[Fatalis]

Just to be clear, I'm not defending I.D., but I'd be more persuaded by the "scientists only" rules on the clubhouse door if so many scientists didn't ignore or make excuses for the theological pretensions of people like Gould or Weinberg. One doesn't need to be a scientist to understand the basics of the scientific method, and to see that I.D. doesn't follow it.