Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: ConYoungBlack

OK, so now for my "critique" without humor.

It is, indeed, a very well written article with a few, minor spelling and grammatical errors as pointed out by another poster.

However, with regard to the "gay marriage" thing or for that matter even tolerating gays in any way to begin with, I have never seen anyone approach it from this standpoint and it by no means has to have a "religious backbone":

Why not use the argument that "gay" relationships are not "reproductive," period. As stated, it doesn't have to be based on religion at all. It's just counter to sustaining the human race.

Why not apply that same logic to abortion and keep religion out of it, if for no other reason than to keep the lefties from screaming, "Religious zealot?" When a leftie asks about abortion just reply, "It's not reproductive and is not in the best interests of bettering the human race." That should silence anyone.

One doesn't even have to mention religion at all using these answers. Again, to be used only to keep the socialists from screaming and crying out that we are religious zealots. If one can keep the religious argument out of it then that just makes it a "neater" package.

Let's tackle our religious aspects on its own merit and as a separate part of the ideals.

Otherwise, I disagree with "Michael Moore walking the plank." How about keel-hauling him? :-)

( As an aside, with reference to the "reproductive" thing I have to give credit where credit is due. That would be John Brodie, a Hall of Fame quarterback of the San Francisco 49ers in the 60s and 70s. There are some football players who are deep thinkers. ) :-)


80 posted on 11/06/2004 8:28:37 AM PST by El Gran Salseron (My wife just won the "Inmate of the Month" Award! :-))
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]


To: El Gran Salseron
Why not use the argument that "gay" relationships are not "reproductive," period. As stated, it doesn't have to be based on religion at all. It's just counter to sustaining the human race.

I agree that another argument outside of religion needs to be used against the gay lifestyle.

1) It is unhealthy. The average lifespan of gays is extreemly short. The same people who carp about smoking and McDonalds are being hypocritical.

2) It is "unnatural". The best line I've seen on this is from Dr. Laura who said "Penis, Vagina, what is it that you don't understand"?

3) There are innumerable studies that say that children need both a father and mother. And even if the "family" doesn't intend on having children, the example set that male-female couples is the "proper" family is good for the community. If others want to break these traditions, fine. But let's not encurage it with social custom.

Why not apply that same logic to abortion and keep religion out of it, if for no other reason than to keep the lefties from screaming, "Religious zealot?" When a leftie asks about abortion just reply, "It's not reproductive and is not in the best interests of bettering the human race." That should silence anyone.

This is even easier.

1) If it is important to give rights to all people. Then it is equally important to give rights to unborn people as well. The Constitution does not discriminate against unborn people.

2) Roe vs. Wade is just bad law. There is no legitimate Constitutional right of privacy that allows the Dr. Patient relationship to do anything it wants. Hell, we don't even allow Doctors the "privacy" to prescribe many drugs. And in that case there certianly is no third human involved. Dr. Kevorkian didn't have the right of privacy to conspire with his patients to kill them. He ended up in jail.

3) People might argue the merrits of abortion, but Roe sets a bad precident that the courts can just make up law. I would think that this would be anathema to good liberals, because some boogyman like John Ashcroft could come along and do real damage against them by bypassing the Congress and getting 5 justices to do his bidding.

96 posted on 11/06/2004 9:28:55 AM PST by narby (WE are now the Mainstream - Enjoy)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 80 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson