I knew it was too good to be true! You did say, though, that criminals have no rights. And that "You lose your civil rights to avoid violence at the hands of others as soon as you step onto another's property and proceed to commit crimes. I referenced the law of my state on this matter already here". That's a direct quote. So, I say the guy has come onto my property and commited a crime.
What's stupid is thinking that arbitrary, vigilante, lynch mob justice is workable in a civilized society.
I agree. However, in the event we wish to move in that direction, we could in fact model our justice system on the Taliban's.