[billbears]

Note that change corresponds with the beginning of the decline of the Republic.

No, the Republic was already in decline. This was just one of the final nails in the coffin.

This would be a good thing. Of course, 'conservatives' everywhere will rip Keyes for daring to suggest returning the government to the form the Founders intended. We wouldn't be able to cheer on 'our' side as if running the federal government was some sort of king of the hill game. If the 17th were overturned, what would Senators do? Why they would be left to the business of maintaining the national government instead of fighting over pork for their state and TV time for their ridiculous soundbites

[Repairman Jack]

I think you're correct. It really started to decline in 1861.

[4CJ]

This would be a good thing.

Yep. Kudos to Ambassodor Keyes and GA Sen. Zell Miller, both men who understand that Senators should represent the states against the federal behemouth, not to be a part of it.

[sheltonmac]

This would be a good thing.

I disagree. This would be a great thing.