[IronJack]

I think the comparison is strained; even the author draws no real similarity -- other than the broad theme of Good vs. Evil -- between the two works. But I agree with his analysis of each work individually.

I wouldn't make too much of the symbolism in LOTR. In the end, it is a myth. A very complete and compelling myth, to be sure. But a story as old as Time, populated by mysterious sylvan creatures and shadowy, looming demons. A ripping good yarn.

[Taka No Kimi]

I wouldn't make too much of the symbolism in LOTR. In the end, it is a myth. A very complete and compelling myth, to be sure. But a story as old as Time, populated by mysterious sylvan creatures and shadowy, looming demons. A ripping good yarn.

Too true, too true!