[pete anderson]

Only if they're alive.

And do you propose we kill a billion Muslims? If that is you idea on how we should solve our "Islam Problem" you may want to give President Bush a call and see if he is on board with your theory.

[CatoRenasci]

No, of course not. But, I think if we killed a whole lot of the ones shouting "Death to America" it might not be a bad idea.

[FreedomCalls]

And do you propose we kill a billion Muslims?

Did we kill every German to eliminate the Nazi threat?
Did we kill every Japanese to eliminate the Japanese Imperialist threat?
Did we kill every Russian to eliminate the Communist threat?
Then why would we kill every Muslim to eliminate the terrorist threat?

Did we eliminate the Nazi threat without killing any innocent Germans? No.
Did we eliminate the Japanese Imperialist threat without killing any innocent Japanese? No.
Did we eliminate the communist threat without killing any innocent Russians? Perhaps, but it took 50 years of hard effort "to bear any burden, pay any price".
Can we eliminate the terrorist threat without killing any innocent Muslims? No.
Will it take 50 years? Maybe. It could even take longer. Is it worth it? You choose. The problem is that many on the left have chosen and they have chosen the other side. They would prefer a world where women are hidden under burkhas and gays are stoned to death. Where men can leave their women and children just by saying "I divorce you" three times. Where science and progress and considered evil. Where freedom is such an alien concept that it isn't even understood much less defended or sought after.