Actually, I kinda felt the same way about "Midnight At The Oasis." I thought THAT was a great song.
I think I've figured this all out, though.
One's idea of a "great song" has much to do with what or whom one associates said song.
In my case, "Midnight At The Oasis" is associated with a blonde name Dawn, Yankton South Dakota, circa 1974, whereas that awful "Love Will Keep Us Together" song reminds me of Jimmy Carter.
Think I might be on to something?
...perhaps, employing a hitherto unknown definition of the word 'great'.
You mean it's a "grate" song, as in, "It makes me want to take the 45 and use a cheese grater on it."