No, I said, "We know there is a supernatural, because it was written about in a book and told to us by a guy who wanted 10% of what we earned."
Now maybe you've been talking to Jesus and the disciples, but I doubt you're 2,000 years old. More likely than not you're relying on what you were told by someone who also wasn't there, and who, by the way, wants you to not just rattle that plate next time.
Thank goodness there are no scientists who want a piece of my paycheck...