[walden]

He has a long, detailed rebuttal to the charges linked from his website, but as I read somewhere, he was allowed only a page or two in the magazine to respond to the lengthy original mag piece. Is that right?

[Doctor Stochastic]

Yes, he was allowed to respond. SA is not required to reprint his book to criticize it. The previous post claimed that he wasn't allowed to respond in the magazine; that claim was false.