Every on of those "authors” has been exposed as anti-Catholic hacks. I'm surprised that you haven’t brought Ian Paisley in to this "discussion". Really? Carroll, Goldhagen and Zuccotti have been exposed as "anti-catholic hacks. That will come as quite a surprise to the NY Times and the Yale review of books. I don't suppose you have a slew of nationally reputable sources for this, other than from pro-catholic journals?
Out of curiosity do you practice any one faith? do you beleive in G-d? I thought you might be Jewish and now I think you might be an agnostic....