[Sabertooth]

anyone can style himself a paleo and not be an anti-Semite, but it seems more than a little curious to me that, among the professional writers who style themselves paleocons these days, they tend to eminate the same wavelength on the Israel question and tend to eminate it quite brightly.

Yeah, and Klansmen and Aryan Nations trolls style themselves as Christians, giving anti-Christians fuel for whatever demagogic flames they might want to throw.

I'm a wee bit leary of broadbrushed labelization.

[AmishDude]

That's my point. Anybody can point to a fringe element and say "See, that guy is nasty so all people who belong to a group he claims to belong to are nasty."

But look at the modern paleocon movement. I really don't see any professional writer who's a paleocon who doesn't at least have a tinge of anti-Semitism.

Reese, Sobran, Buchanan, even the goofs at antiwar.com. Whatever the paleocon movement may have been, these people define it today.