I'll chalk it up to different tastes in what I want out of an analyst.
FWIW, I can't handle any of the ABC/ESPN/TNT crews. I'll stick with Jim Paschke and John McGlocklin (the Bucks' TV crew).
No argument about the network line up for NBA crews. I've seen McGlocklin a few times, but can't say that he made an impression. I remember him as a player though. Great shooter.