Great analysis! I hadn't separated the Moral layer from the Nationalist layer. I've kind of adopted the idea that the Constitution and the idea of freedom form a kind of Nationalist ideal which our current govt hardly lives up to, but the Socialist Govt we're stuck with is limited in how much additional damage they can do by grass roots activists trying to reestablish the principles of a true Constitutional Republic. In essence We the People are the final fourth Check and Balance. Without a better background in political science, I wonder if the upcoming generations are going to be as good an instrument of guidance to the other three branches.
Maybe the determining factor for the survival of a socialist regime wrapping itself in a Constitutional Republic's guise is when sedition, outside threats or economic intrusions are viewed by a sufficient majority as no worse than the state of affairs in the govt at the time. But what a horror to think that the Constitution's Principles would perish from humanity. There is a dignity and aesthetic to letting people have freedom to direct their activities to what their hearts desire with as little intrusion by the will of the mob as possible. A recognition of the potential in each person that is greater than any religious system...Maybe its just progress worship...I don't know...It gives me hope. It sounds like Europe has lost even that.
At the time of the adoption of the Constitution, the feds had no power to do ANYTHING without the general support of a majority of the people. The US had just finished with the Revolution, the people were armed, and they had military experience
Consider this scenario: you are a bureaucrat tasked with enforcing an unpopular law. You have a paper on your desk telling you to arrest Joe Shmoe. You know that Joe is armed, all his neighbors are armed, they're trained to operate together as a military unit, and they don't like you. If you were the bureaucrat, how likely would you be to "lose" that order into your wastebasket?
The unique thing about American life was that power and authority flowed from the bottom up, rather than the top down. Local law-enforcement was done by sheriffs who were elected by the locals, rather than being appointed by a provincial governor who was appointed by the King. There were lots of local authority figures who could serve as rallying points for insurrection. This is slowly being chipped away as local authorities grow increasingly dependent on federal funds, and thus become puppets of federal authorities