[Askel5]

No, they are not anti-Semitic, just meshugena

Ah ... Jews who critize the STATE of Israel are "insane".

(Your signaturely leftist smear of mental instability is noted.)

In your strictly personal opinion, is there any criticism of the STATE of Israel which does not denote either anti-semitism (in the case of Gentiles) or insanity (in the case of Jews)?

[veronica]

I have stated my opinion of this tiny group. Feel free to continue to debate this issue at your pleasure.

[BenF]

is there any criticism of the STATE of Israel which does not denote either anti-semitism (in the case of Gentiles) or insanity (in the case of Jews)?

I hope you don't mind me responding to this. The answer to your question is "yes". For example, I criticize the State of Israel frequently for not exterminating terrorists. My concern is the preservation of Jewish life and faith. Criticism of Israel which is based on this concern is NOT anti-Semitic.

[Dec31,1999]

So let me get this straight. We're supposd to wage a war over these Semitic (Arabs are Semites, too) fairy tales?