[jwalsh07]

It is a false statement, and a statement that lacks the depth of debate and allows for opponents to be discounted by using 911 as a means to silence them.

I happen to think its a true statementa. And I'll give you an example. The debate over whether the terrorists are detainees or pow's can aid the bad guys immensely.

If they are pow's, we are entitled to name, rank and service number and thats it. No questioning which means no information on planned terrorist attacks and more dead Americans.

IMHO, those arguing that Al Quaeda are being denied liberty by being classified detainees rather than pow's is exactly the sought of thing Ashcroft was talking about.

[francisandbeans]

This statement was made prior to the detainees being brought here.

[AUgrad]

IMHO, those arguing that Al Quaeda are being denied liberty by being classified detainees rather than pow's is exactly the sought of thing Ashcroft was talking about.

I hope you are correct. I personally felt his statement was more ominous. By the way, I agree ,the detainees should not be classified as POWs. However, I feel they should be proven guilty in court or tribunal before execution.