[Gordian Blade]

Another question for you: What you have there (the post I'm replying to) is a quote from the Bible. Can you quote directly from JRRT specifically about Arwen?

[SlickWillard]

Can you quote directly from JRRT specifically about Arwen?

I don't know how Tolkien could have said it any more clearly:

But Arwen became as a mortal woman, and yet it was not her lot to die until all that she had gained was lost.

She gained The Gift of Men, the she lost it.

[SlickWillard]

She gained The Gift of Men, then she lost it.