[SamAdams76]

Gee, we might as well compare Charles Dickens and Dr. Suess while we're at it. Does Oliver Twist measure up against Green Eggs And Ham? Let's discuss.

Comparing Tolkien to Rowling is silliness. J.K. Rowling is the author of children's books. Tolkien writes for an adult audience (though many older children can enjoy his works as well).

[Cicero]

Well, yes. But The Hobbit is a much better book than Harry Potter too. And I like Harry Potter, what's more. I think Rowling is a real find. It's just that Tolkien isn't someone I'd want to try to compete with. I'm also a great fan of C. S. Lewis's, and I think I've read all of his books, but he wasn't in the same league with Tolkien either.

You're certainly right to say that it's apples and oranges. Harry Potter is an entertaining children's book. The Lord of the Rings may be one of the greatest books of the twentieth century, and certainly the best fantasy novel.

[Petronski]

Does Oliver Twist measure up against Green Eggs And Ham? Let's discuss.

One certainly could discuss how intelligently each was conceived and executed.

[Huck]

Golly. I have never read a Tolkien book (I don't read much fiction--about 10%). I take it I am missing out on something good?

[MrConfettiMan]

I was first introduced to Tolkien in my high school British Literature class by Mrs. Buehner. I can't thank her enough. After reading The Hobbit in that class, I took it upon myself to get a copy of The Lord of The Rings. I've read it at least half a dozen times since then and am just about to finish The Fellowship of The Ring in preparation for the movie. I'm currently at the tail end of the Council of Elrond.