[american colleen]

You can't be serious that you use William Webster as your sole source of information about the Catholic Church???

I've read whatever he has on the net. I'm not impressed. He spends more time trying to debunk the Catholic faith (and the Eastern Orthodox) than he does explaining his own. Methinks thou doest protest too much.

At least read the many thoughtful rebuttals written by Catholics in response to Mr. Webster's assertions. Then you can form your own opinions.

[Iowegian]

You haven't explained where you think Webster is wrong, you only attack the author. His work is sourced, he didn't make anything up. You RC's always whine about facts, but when you get them, you ignore them and attack the writer, it's what the boys at Catholic Answers are best at. I've read your guy's stuff, it's weak. More attacks than facts on this subject and many others.