[Kenny Bunk]

You have violated a sacred law:

"Thou shalt nevereverwhatsoever attempt to insert logic into a discussion of the War Between the States."

For your penance, you must sit through "Cold Mountain" three times, or "Gone with the Wind" twice. Go now and sin no more.

[Aurelius]

I think that you have judged her unfairly, I didn't see any logic there.