Pope Francis claimed Our Lady ‘unites’ Christians and Muslims. Here’s why that’s wrong

LifeSite News ^ | May 31, 2024 | Raymond Ibrahim

[delchiante]

Quote
Where was Mary’s second-born son at the foot of the Cross, delchiante?
....

No clue. Joseph wasn’t recorded as being there either.

Maybe that’s why Christ told his mother to live with one of His mighty ones at the cross who followed Him.

[delchiante]

Perpetual vs not perpetual.
Flip a coin..

50/50 chance

[ebb tide]

I’d suggest fleeing, but that’s just me.

Bingo! It's just you and I don't give a flip about your opinions.

[delchiante]

Quote
Bingo! It’s just you and I don’t give a flip about your opinions.
.....

I didn’t come up with that all myself..

It’s the warning to flee Babylon within the scriptures..

I just have a different opinion of what Babylon is than you..

And yup, that’s the product of testing and proving All things with the scriptures.

Eyes and ears can be quite a thing. They can look open yet unable to see and hear what others may be able to see and hear.

And that’s all for His Glory. Not mine..

[ebb tide]

No clue.

Exactly! You haven't a clue as to what you are talking about.

[ealgeone]

For the RCs who post against their pope I offer this reminder that they have to be subject to their pope. And considering how some deny he's the pope....well....doesn't sound like they're being subject to the Roman Pontiff now does it?

*****

Pope Boniface VIII in his Papal Bull Unam Sanctam (A.D. 1302): "We declare, say, define, and pronounce that it is absolutely necessary for the salvation of every human creature to be subject to the Roman Pontiff."

[CA Conservative]

“ Where was Mary’s second-born son at the foot of the Cross, delchiante?”

Are you referring to James, the brother of Jesus who later became the head of the church at Jerusalem? Or perhaps you are thinking of Joses or Jude or Simon, all of whom the Bible mentions as His brothers (Adelphoi , Greek for “of the same womb”)? Of course, there are also His sisters mentioned as well.

[ebb tide]

No, I'm not.

Our Lord, Jesus Christ, had no siblings.

But if you want to believe what the muslims believe; that's on you.

[Trump_Triumphant]

Even if what you say is true(it’s not), what is so heretical to call Mary perpetual virgin? It was almost universally held in the early Church. The original Reformers believed it. Why the obsession of so many non Catholics(and non-Orthodox) over this issue?

[CA Conservative]

I’m believing what the Bible says. And it says He had brothers and sisters.

[ebb tide]

I’m believing what the Bible says. And it says He had brothers and sisters.

Do you believe:

 23 Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them; and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained  [John 20:23]

[ebb tide]

I offer this reminder that they have to be subject to their pope.

What Catholic would take advice from one who attacks the Catholic Church?

[CA Conservative]

Yes, I believe that was given to the Apostles. However, I find nothing in any of the subsequent books to support the idea that this was to be passed down to others. Even Peter, on the day of Pentecost, did not say “come confess your sins to one of us and receive absolution”; he said “repent and be baptized every one of you for the remission of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Ghost”.

[ebb tide]

Those poor prots just keep getting further and further away from the True Faith. It's just what Satan wants.

Martin Luther's Devotion to Mary

[ealgeone]

What Catholic would take advice from one who attacks the Catholic Church?

*****

I guess you're not Roman Catholic....considering the daily anti-pope articles you put up.

I guess OMCET is its own denomination.

[ealgeone]

Even if what you say is true(it’s not), what is so heretical to call Mary perpetual virgin? It was almost universally held in the early Church.

No, that's not quite right.

The earliest writers of the NT affirmed Joseph and Mary did have children of their own after the birth of Jesus. Which was not a sin in any way. In fact, it was very natural for that to happen.

And please....don't try to play the brothers can mean something other than biological sibling card. It'd be repeating a failed apologetic from Catholic Answers.

Oh, and not the, "show me in the Bible where it says Joseph and Mary had sexual relations" card either. It's really a futile argument for the RC to try that as it's so easily dismissed with a couple of questions.

[ebb tide]

Ask me if I care about what an anti-Catholic thinks.

[ealgeone]

That’s why you’re OMCET....one member church of ebb tide. You only care about you and your anti-pope tirade.

[ebb tide]

I find it amusing that one who can’t even spell “eagle” is so dead-set on defending Jorge the Heretic. He must also be a pro-homo, pro-tree hugging, pro-illegal and pro-death vax like his hero, Jorge.

When will this Bergoglio fanatic again pull out the old scapular personal attack?

[ealgeone]

You continue to prove my point in these discussions that it is usually, though not always, the Roman Catholic (?), or OMCET member, who first resorts to the personal attack and or profanity when the argument goes against them….which is often.

The guilt of wearing that idol called the scapular must be getting to you.