Murdered Catholic Priest Knew Too Much?

Catholic Online ^ | March 3, 2004 | Matt Abbott

[GirlShortstop]

I has been decided? Oh, really? WHO decided, pray tell? Not the Pope. Not the Cardinal. Not anyone.

READ IT AGAIN

Even after you posit once again ultima, Schism remains a SIN... it has been decided and determined. SSPX is in SCHISM.

If schism is not a sin, and SSPX is not in SCHISM, then what inhibits you from saying YES or NO to whether or not you adhere to SSPX?

The rest of your post will be read later.  Good night.

[ultima ratio]

Complete nonsense.

1. No bishop, no matter how high up in the Vatican, can excommunicate another bishop. That is impossible.

2. This document by Card. Gantin is not a decree of excommunication. It mentions that a latae sententiae excommunication had occurred. But the cardinal couldn't know this, he is only surmising something. Latae senentiae is something that happens automatically when someone violates certain canons of Canon Law. But there are specific exemptions also written into law. If one or several of these is evoked, there is no excommunication.

[ninenot]

You are wasting bandwidth, although you've learned a lot about researching Vatican documents.

THAT should come in handy sometime.

[GirlShortstop]

You are wasting bandwidth, although you've learned a lot about researching Vatican documents.

THAT should come in handy sometime.

You are probably right ninenot.  An obstinence about (what appears to be) lies has resulted in garnering some good information for me, and I hope, others.  BlackElk's posts, you very well know, they're *always* chock-full of good stuff!  :-)
Whistling now "Always look on the bright side of life..."
FReegards!