To: HURRICANE FORCE; Alter Kaker
Just found this, thought it was interesting, it was with the photo of him throwing the rocks:
link
"People who live in glass houses...
"Well-known Palestinian American academic, Edward Said, has embroiled himself in further controversy regarding his conduct. Late last year, a storm brewed up over the revelations produced by Justus Reid Weiner that Said had systematically mis-represented himself for several decades as a Palestinian refugee forcibly evicted by Israel, when in fact he spent an affluent childhood in Cairo.
"Said has described Weiners findings as a tissue of lies, yet implicitly conceded their accuracy in the corrected version that now appears in his own memoir, Out of Place."
To: texasbluebell
I can't believe the article repeated the lie that Said was born in Jerusalem. It has been conclusively proven that Said was born to an upper-middle class family in Cairo, then under nominal British control. His story, as we learned, was completely false. Said attended a posh private school in Cairo. And in July 2000, Said was photographed throwing rocks over the Lebanese border into Israel, attempting to hit Israelis on the other side. The Columbia Daily Spectator, his own universitys student paper, commented that his hypocritical violent action was alien to this or any other institution of higher learning.
44 posted on
09/25/2003 9:07:31 AM PDT by
Recourse
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson