I'd give Gagne Firemean of the Year, barring some late season brilliance from Smoltz.
I'm a bit of a stickler, though, on how the awards should be given. I think it's silly that a reliever can win FotY, CyYoung, and MVP.
Barring once-every-half-century performances, MVPs should go to position players, and Cy Youngs should go to starters.
Besides, Gagne gave up Bonds' 500th stolen base, and lost that game as a result.
Bonds is MVP again, btw (too bad for Pujols, who won't make the playoffs), and Schmidt is Cy Young if he has a strong September. CY is up in the air, otherwise. Ortiz, maybe.