Posted on 08/31/2003 3:02:36 PM PDT by Willie Green
For education and discussion only. Not for commercial use.
LONDON, Aug. 30 — One of the largest oil companies in the world, Royal Dutch/Shell, has promised to avoid exploring or drilling on sites that carry the United Nation's World Heritage designation. It is the first energy company to make such a promise.
Shell's decision comes a week after the International Council on Mining and Metals, a group of the world's 15 largest mining companies, said it would stop exploring or mining on World Heritage sites.
Taken together, the commitments are a "big step forward," said Dr. Mechtild Rossler, director of European heritage for Unesco, the United Nations agency that controls the program. "We would have liked to see a more global picture with the gas and oil industry, but Shell is a good starting point."
More than 170 countries take part in the World Heritage program, which was founded in 1972 to identify, protect and preserve cultural or natural areas that provide "outstanding value to humanity." The United States was the first country to sign on to the program.
A site is nominated by a local government, and the application is reviewed by Unesco, which can take as long as five years. If the site is approved, the 170 countries pledge to help protect it.
The oil and mining pledges are part of larger movement by corporations to designate some areas as "no go" zones, environmentalists said. Shell and the mining companies have "decided there is more shareholder value to their reputation than the resources" they could tap in World Heritage sites, said Rob Lake, director of corporate governance at Henderson's Global Investors in London, which manages $152 billion in assets.
Shell's promise is unlikely to have any effect on the company's current business because most World Heritage sites are not oil-rich. But the decision could have some practical effect. The Wadden Sea, an area with abundant natural gas off the coast of the Netherlands, is on the World Heritage's tentative site list, along with the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska. President Bush's energy plan includes opening the Alaskan range to drilling.
Shell did have plans to explore for oil and gas in the Sundarbans region of Bangladesh, a World Heritage site since 1997 that houses the world's largest mangrove forest. It abandoned the idea in 2001 after pressure from environmentalists.
Sir Philip Watts, the Shell chairman, announced the plans in a speech at the headquarters of the World Conservation Union in Geneva on Thursday.
Some environmentalists said that they welcomed Shell's promise but that it did not go far enough. "It's such a small step, it is hard to rejoice," said Michael Brune, executive director of the Rainforest Action Network, an environmental group in San Francisco. "I suppose you could call it a conceptual breakthrough for an oil company to say it won't drill in the Grand Canyon or on the Galápagos Islands, but any school kid can tell you they shouldn't."
Mining, drilling and logging on World Heritage sites are not unheard of, and often cause bitter battles between international conservationists and local governments, which say the activities are dictated by economics. In 1998, the mining company Energy Resources of Australia started digging for uranium in Kakadu Park, a wetland in the Northern Territories that had been a World Heritage site since 1981. Loggers and environmentalists also have clashed over the use of a World Heritage-designated rain forest in Honduras.
In other instances, World Heritage sites have suffered when local governments do not have the resources to protect them.
Analysts say it is easier for Shell to rule out drilling in World Heritage sites than it is for its peers. "Shell has a much more diverse resource base" than the competition, with reserves it can tap around the world, said Doug Leggate, a Citigroup oil analyst.
I'd say that energy production provides "outstanding value to humanity."
Let me know if you wish to be added or removed from this list.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.