Careful now JR, you're starting to paint yourself into a corner.
What if Muslims gain control of a city council let's say in Dearborne Mich. where there is a big concentration of them and they declare that henceforth Sharia law complete with amputations and stonings will be the only recognized law.
Still OK with you?
After all, it's according to the will of "the people".
Actually, that's why Jefferson thought that Christian values should be supreme. And that's what Moore was saying when he noted that it is Judeo Christianity that allows us to protect the rights of disbelievers.
Our Consitution dovetails very nicely with fundamental Christianity. It doesn't do so with fundamental Islam.