[Cachelot]

Second, the equation of anti-Semitism with genocide is wrong and outrageous

You're saying that it's outrageous to claim that antisemitism led to genocide? That antisemitism is generally respectable, and that Hitler was an aberration among antisemites?

Well.. guess we'll have to be careful not to tar all antisemites (particularly those who're just perpetrating the ol' "Christkiller" blood-libel) with the Hitler brush then, won't we?

Sick puppies on display. FR seems to have an unending supply of them.

[ultima ratio]

Anti-Semitism is never respectable--but then, neither is anti-Catholicism or any other form of prejudice. Hitler's genocidal hatred was not of that order. It was sui generis.

[veronica]

Discussions about this movie sure brings out the anti-semites. Mel Gibson's deliberate slow "rollout" of his film is having the unintended (I hope) consequence of fomenting animus against Jews, mostly among those so inclined already. A shame really. Why doesn't he just premiere the movie when it's done, like most directors do?