But, this is not the central question, is it?
Reasonable vs. logical.
"Reason" is subject to individual interpretation. Logic whether propositional or categorical, has a set method for arriving at a conclusion.
Aristotle's categorical logic is a brilliant system to evaluate claims of "reason."
Is that something you just came up with? Because the courts have been using the "reasonable person" standard for years.
It effectively and justifiably dismisses the frivolous, ridiculous, and overblown fearmongering that's inherent in passionate debate, as we've seen with this issue.