[m1911]

He doesn't say (in that bit, anyway) that Ann lied or exaggerated - he says Joe McCarthy did.

[Hugin]

He doesn't say (in that bit, anyway) that Ann lied or exaggerated - he says Joe McCarthy did.

The whole point of Ann's book is that he did not lie and any exaggeration were minor and inconsequntial. This guy ridicules her thesis without making any serious attempt to back up his claims about McCarthy.

Have you read Ann's book? If not you should.