[Jhoffa_]

Can you show me the logical fallacy in my argument?

Sure..

1) What will you charge me with if I build a boat for my own pleasure?

2) What exemption do you claim from copyright law?

As I said, good luck in court.

You'll need it.

[Hajman]

1) What will you charge me with if I build a boat for my own pleasure?

I will charge you nothing (expect whatever comes from copyright infringment). If you make a copy of my song, I will charge you nothing (expect whatever comes from copyright infringment).

2) What exemption do you claim from copyright law?

None. It'd be copyright infringment, not theft. What exemption would I apply to music? The same thing. My argument is logically consistent. Your's (claiming the boat copy isn't theft, but claiming the song copy is), isn't consistent, therefore isn't valid.

-The Hajman-