[DannyTN]

The problem is who is going to police this. Who is going to make sure that the downloader knows it is an illegal song. Who is going to make sure that the technology isn't abused. This is letting the record companies be judge, jury and executioner.

[ThinkDifferent]

This is letting the record companies be judge, jury and executioner.

Exactly. I'm astounded that Hatch is seriously proposing this. I thought he might have a clue based on some of his comments about problems with the DMCA, but apparently not.