[MEG33]

They did not have the right to make that decision for our country.We are a republic and vote on our leaders to lead.They did not have the ultimate power or the responsibility to make those decisions.

[liberallarry]

They did not have the right to make that decision for our country.We are a republic and vote on our leaders to lead.They did not have the ultimate power or the responsibility to make those decisions

They had the power they had and they exercised it. Dispense with a utopian view of our system as you insist others dispense with a utopian view of other systems.

[liberallarry]

They did not have the right to make that decision for our country

I wonder if I haven't misunderstood you on this one?

If thought you were arguing against improper influence of men like Szilard. You may have thought that I was justifying spying.

To be clear.

I think Szilard, and other scientists, exercised their influence to the extent they could. Quite properly. Lots of groups have influence far beyond their numbers. That's how the system really works.

In no way did I mean to justify the actions of spies or those who illegaly violated the secrecy laws. My arguments were meant to show that it was extremely unlikely that first-rate scientists would have sympathized with the Russians enough to betray America. They had other motivations. In those few cases where that motivation led them to treason I have no problem with punishment. They deserved it.