[r9etb]

Your criticism, This contradicts "A is A," (your father never did anything?) and it also requires you to assume ... an assumption (or any other mental phenomenon is an action and all action requires change)You cannot imply an action in your refutation of dynamism.

If there is dynamism, then it means at least some things can change. "A is A," implies that nothing can change. So either dynamism is not universally true, or "A is not always A."

[Hank Kerchief]

If there is dynamism, then it means at least some things can change. "A is A," implies that nothing can change. So either dynamism is not universally true, or "A is not always A."

Not at all. A is A is shorthand for a thing is what it is. A is A applies to anything which can be identified and comprehended by means of a concept, an entity, an event, a relationship, or even another concept. A is A in no way implies there is no change.

Change does not mean change from one thing into another. Your precious quarks, do they not move. A quark is a qaurk, but it changes position.

Hank