Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: longshadow
The biggest problem with Rand is she is a dialectisit in the Grand ol' tradition of Hegel and Marx. She's just a right wing dialectisist. Dialectisits like to pretend that the dualities like "reason and emotion" , "theory and practice" , "government and the governed" are hindering the progress of society and can be eliminated so as to create a perfect society. She also takes a natural rights approach to everything which is not going to convince people who have different metaphysical principles, especially the devoutly religious.

Far Far better of a conservative is Ludwig Von Mises who basically argued for the free market not from a natural rights approach but from the idea that socialists always would get the opposite of what they were aiming at because of problems of information, calculation and valuation. All his predictions about what would cause the systematic failure of communism came true and he made these back in the early 1920s when Russia had just had it's revolution. He didn't base his arguments on the idea that Communism is immoral, etc. He just said that it was broken in that it would fail miserably to accomplish it's ends for various systemic reasons that he explains in great detail. Go read "Economic Calculation in the Socialist Commonwealth" over at Mises.org and you will be amazed at his brilliance.

56 posted on 04/22/2003 7:15:30 PM PDT by Odyssey-x
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 10 | View Replies ]


To: Odyssey-x
He didn't base his arguments on the idea that Communism is immoral, etc. He just said that it was broken in that it would fail miserably to accomplish it's ends for various systemic reasons that he explains in great detail.

Well, just for the record, I am an admirer of von Mises, as well as Rand.

There's nothing wrong with a pragmatic indictment of Communism, per se. The trouble is that the pragmatic argument fails if they manage to hold things together (Mainland China comes to mind). Rand, OTOH, provides a powerful moral argument against Communism (or any form of totalitarianism) that is immune to the vulnerabilities of the pragmatic argument.

On balance, I think there's a great deal we can learn from both Rand AND von Mises.

75 posted on 04/22/2003 7:52:50 PM PDT by longshadow
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 56 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson