[WhiskeyPapa]

You keep repeating the same old garbage. Insurrection is mentioned in the Militia Act, not a state withdrawing. Two different things.

Under the law, the president makes that decision.

Walt

[HenryLeeII]

No, Walter, the president does not have the power to declare an unrelated act as an insurrection. He has the power to call out the militia during an insurrection, and even the power to determine at what point armed threats to the extant authority or mob actions may be considered to be insurrection, but he does not have the power to declare other acts, reflective of powers reserved by the states, as insurrection. The fact that you have admitted that there is no Constitutional language or Federal law prohibiting a state from withdrawing, and then sunk to the level of appealing to a newspaper editorial for justification, shows you to be in the same boat as Baghdad Bob during the last days of Baathist power. You dropped the flag and Non-Sequitur picked it up to continue the charge, but he will have the same results as Sisyphus struggling in vain as the boulder that is the Tenth Amendment will not budge!